Sorry, item "offcanvas-col1" does not exist.
Sorry, item "offcanvas-col2" does not exist.
Sorry, item "offcanvas-col3" does not exist.
Sorry, item "offcanvas-col4" does not exist.
Hit enter to search or ESC to close
At Miromico, peer reviews have become an indispensable part of our hardware design process. They ensure consistent quality, but they can also turn into a ping-pong match if not handled well—jeopardizing production deadlines.
Here’s how we strike the balance between thoroughness and progress:
1. Start with a Solid Foundation
Every project begins with a specification document, which aligns the hardware designer, reviewer, and product manager.
2. Set Clear Timelines for Reviews
We establish specific deadlines for each review stage to keep the process moving efficiently. This ensures that reviews do not become bottlenecks while maintaining quality standards.
3. Embed Reviews in the Workflow
We integrate a three-to-four-stage review process into our timeline:
- Component Review
- Specification & Schematic Review
- (Optional) Component Placement Review
- Layout Review
4. Guidelines, Not Chains
Our design guidelines minimize review overhead while allowing space for creativity. After all, PCB design is as much art as it is engineering!
5. Customize the Scope and Process
Using template checklists, tailored for each design, helps define the review’s focus. Each review iteration uses these checklists to ensure consistency and completeness, and every checklist is versioned for traceability. Designers are encouraged to note their doubts directly into the checklist to streamline feedback.
6. Feedback > Revisions
We believe in feedback over interference. Reviewers at Miromico provide constructive, educational insights** without altering the original design. This respects individual styles and empowers designers to learn and improve.
7. Learn from Every Review
We integrate insights from peer reviews into our design guidelines and processes, creating a culture of continuous improvement. Every review is a step toward better designs and stronger collaboration.
By following these principles, we ensure our reviews elevate the design process rather than slow it down.
How does your team approach peer reviews in hardware design? Let’s discuss!
Think IoT - Think Miromico!